How Long Does Solar Take to Pay Off With Your Utility? (2026)
Your state doesn't decide whether solar pays off. Your electric company does.
We calculated simple payback for a typical 12 kW home solar system for customers of 19 utility territories in Pennsylvania, Ohio, Virginia, West Virginia, Michigan and Mississippi. The answer ranges from 8.7 years (Duquesne Light, Pittsburgh) to 21.4 years (Mon Power, West Virginia), and it can swing by more than three years inside a single state.
These numbers assume no federal tax credit. The 30% residential solar credit (Section 25D) ended for systems installed after December 31, 2025. They also leave out state and utility incentives, which would shorten payback where they apply.
Key findings
- Fastest: Duquesne Light (Pittsburgh), 8.7 years. It has the least sunshine of all 19 locations, but the highest residential rate (25.1¢/kWh) and 1:1 credit for exported power.
- Slowest: Mon Power (West Virginia), 21.4 years. Cheap power (14.5¢/kWh) and an export credit of about 9¢ mean each kWh of solar saves less.
- Export rules split the map in two. Utilities that credit exports at or near retail (Pennsylvania, Virginia, Michigan) land between 8.7 and 12.1 years. Those that pay 5–9¢ for exports (Ohio, Mississippi, West Virginia) land between 15.8 and 21.4.
- What you're paid per kWh matters far more than sun. Across these 19 utilities, the value of each solar kWh (rate plus export credit) explains about 82% of the difference in payback. The rate alone explains about 51%; sunshine about 2%.
- Median payback across the 19: 16.1 years.
Solar payback by utility, fastest to slowest
Click any column heading to re-sort. On mobile, swipe the table sideways.
| Utility | State | Residential customers | Avg. rate ¢/kWh | Export credit ¢/kWh | Solar output kWh/kW/yr | 12 kW cost before incentives | Year-1 savings | Payback years | Rate for 10-yr payback | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Duquesne Light | PA | 441,786 | 25.1¢ | Retail | 1,191 | $31,320 | $3,593 | 8.7 | 21.9¢ | Good |
| PECO | PA | 1,243,560 | 19.3¢ | Retail | 1,359 | $31,320 | $3,147 | 10.0 | 19.2¢ | Good |
| FirstEnergy Pennsylvania | PA | 1,486,178 | 20.2¢ | Retail | 1,268 | $31,320 | $3,075 | 10.2 | 20.6¢ | Good |
| Dominion Energy Virginia | VA | 2,422,977 | 17.0¢ | Retail | 1,427 | $30,720 | $2,913 | 10.5 | 17.9¢ | Good |
| PPL Electric | PA | 842,092 | 19.9¢ | 17.5¢ | 1,276 | $31,320 | $2,821 | 11.1 | 22.0¢ | Marginal |
| DTE Electric | MI | 2,084,483 | 21.7¢ | 16.8¢ | 1,291 | $34,320 | $2,904 | 11.8 | 25.6¢ | Marginal |
| Appalachian Power | VA | 469,247 | 16.5¢ | Retail | 1,288 | $30,720 | $2,552 | 12.0 | 19.9¢ | Marginal |
| Consumers Energy | MI | 1,668,712 | 21.5¢ | 16.6¢ | 1,267 | $34,320 | $2,825 | 12.1 | 26.1¢ | Marginal |
| AEP Ohio | OH | 529,308 | 20.3¢ | 7.1¢ | 1,310 | $30,720 | $1,949 | 15.8 | 32.0¢ | Slow |
| Mississippi Power | MS | 158,373 | 16.4¢ | 5.5¢ | 1,436 | $27,360 | $1,699 | 16.1 | 31.4¢ | Slow |
| AES Ohio (Dayton) | OH | 142,015 | 18.6¢ | 6.5¢ | 1,336 | $30,720 | $1,818 | 16.9 | 31.4¢ | Slow |
| Entergy Mississippi | MS | 383,673 | 15.2¢ | 5.5¢ | 1,414 | $27,360 | $1,588 | 17.2 | 32.1¢ | Slow |
| Cleveland Electric Illuminating | OH | 145,558 | 18.0¢ | 6.3¢ | 1,274 | $30,720 | $1,676 | 18.3 | 32.9¢ | Slow |
| Toledo Edison | OH | 92,698 | 17.4¢ | 6.1¢ | 1,304 | $30,720 | $1,661 | 18.5 | 32.2¢ | Slow |
| Appalachian Power | WV | 348,436 | 17.1¢ | 9.0¢ | 1,232 | $34,440 | $1,810 | 19.0 | 44.7¢ | Slow |
| Duke Energy Ohio | OH | 279,506 | 17.4¢ | 6.1¢ | 1,250 | $30,720 | $1,591 | 19.3 | 33.6¢ | Slow |
| Ohio Edison | OH | 273,793 | 17.3¢ | 6.0¢ | 1,251 | $30,720 | $1,580 | 19.4 | 33.5¢ | Slow |
| Potomac Edison | WV | 139,595 | 12.9¢ | 9.0¢ | 1,301 | $34,440 | $1,651 | 20.9 | 41.6¢ | Slow |
| Mon Power | WV | 334,689 | 14.4¢ | 9.0¢ | 1,200 | $34,440 | $1,610 | 21.4 | 46.3¢ | Slow |
Residential customers = customers on the utility's standard (default) supply, July 2026. Rates are 12-month averages, August 2025 to July 2026. Export credits come from our net metering guide ("Retail" = credited 1:1 at the retail rate); payback assumes 40% of solar output is used at home. Download the full table (CSV).
How to read the last numeric column: if your all-in rate is above this number, solar pays back in under 10 years at today's prices. If it's below, expect longer. To find your rate, divide your bill total by the kWh you used.
What the data shows
Pittsburgh beats sunnier cities because of its electric rate
Pittsburgh produces the least solar power of any city in this study: about 1,191 kWh per installed kW each year, versus 1,436 in Gulfport, Mississippi. It still has the fastest payback, because Duquesne Light's average residential rate (25.1¢/kWh) is the highest of the 19 and Pennsylvania credits exports 1:1. Every kWh your panels produce is worth a more expensive kWh from the grid.
This matches our 50-state solar break-even map, where what a state pays for solar power (its electricity rate together with its export credit) explains about 61% of the difference in payback between states and sunshine almost none.
Two neighbors in one state can have very different answers
- Ohio: AEP Ohio customers (15.8 years) break even more than three years sooner than Ohio Edison customers (19.4 years), mostly because AEP's rate is higher.
- West Virginia: Appalachian Power customers break even in about 19.0 years; Mon Power customers take about 21.4.
- Pennsylvania: all four utility groups land between 8.7 and 11.1 years. PPL is slowest because new systems there get a reduced export credit, about 88% of retail, under a 2026 settlement.
Appalachian Power customers: Virginia vs. West Virginia
The same company serves both states, but payback differs by seven years: about 12.0 years in Virginia and 19.0 years in West Virginia. West Virginia's rate is actually a little higher (17.1¢ vs. 16.5¢). But Virginia credits exported solar 1:1 at retail while West Virginia pays about 9¢, and West Virginia installs cost more ($2.87/W vs. $2.56/W).
Want your actual number? These are averages. Your roof, usage and local quotes decide your real payback. Compare free quotes from vetted installers →
State-by-state quick answers
- Pennsylvania: 8.7 to 11.1 years. Duquesne Light is fastest. Solar in Pennsylvania →
- Ohio: 15.8 to 19.4 years. AEP Ohio is fastest. Solar in Ohio →
- Virginia: 10.5 years (Dominion) and 12.0 years (Appalachian Power). Solar in Virginia →
- Michigan: 11.8 years (DTE) and 12.1 years (Consumers Energy). Solar in Michigan →
- Mississippi: 16.1 years (Mississippi Power) and 17.2 years (Entergy Mississippi). Solar in Mississippi →
- West Virginia: 19.0 to 21.4 years, the slowest in the study. Solar in West Virginia →
Why your own payback may be different
These are averages for a standard system. Your result depends on:
- Your actual rate. If you buy electricity from a retail supplier instead of your utility's standard service (common in Pennsylvania and Ohio), your price per kWh is different from the utility average shown here.
- How much of your solar power you use yourself. We assumed 40% is used at home as it's produced. Where exports earn well below retail (Ohio, Mississippi, West Virginia), using more of your own power, or adding a battery, shortens payback. See net metering by state.
- Your roof. Shade, direction and tilt change output. We assumed an unshaded, south-facing roof.
- Price quotes. Install prices vary between companies. A quote below your state's average shortens payback.
- Incentives. State or utility rebates, where available, would shorten payback. None are included here. See 2026 solar incentives.
- Financing. These figures assume a cash purchase. A loan adds interest cost. With a lease or PPA you don't own the system, so payback works differently. See solar financing options.
Methodology
- Electricity rates. U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) Form 861M: utility-level residential revenue divided by residential sales, summed over August 2025 to July 2026 (the latest data, released September 24, 2026). EIA marks the 2026 months as preliminary. Rates cover customers on the utility's standard (bundled) service.
- Solar production. NLR (National Laboratory of the Rockies, formerly NREL) PVWatts v8: 1 kW system, fixed roof mount, 20° tilt, due south, 14% system losses, modeled at the main city in each utility's territory (listed below).
- Install cost. EnergySage average cost per watt by state, updated November 13, 2026, the same inputs as our state map.
- Export credit. How each utility credits solar sent to the grid, from our Net Metering by State (2026) guide, verified October 31, 2026: 1:1 retail in Pennsylvania and Virginia (about 88% for new PPL systems), about 35% of retail in Ohio, about 77.5% in Michigan, about 5.5¢ in Mississippi and about 9¢ in West Virginia.
- System size. 12 kW.
- Payback. System cost ÷ (annual production × value per kWh), where value per kWh = 40% × the residential rate + 60% × the export credit. That assumes 40% of output is used at home as it's produced. No federal credit, no state or utility incentives, no financing costs, no rate increases and no panel degradation.
- Break-even rate. The electricity rate at which the same system pays back in exactly 10 years.
- Value per kWh vs. sunshine (82% / 2%). The share of variation in payback across these 19 utilities explained by the value of each solar kWh and by solar output (R² of each against payback). The rate alone explains about 51%. With 19 data points and state-level install costs, treat this as directional.
Modeling cities: Duquesne Light (Pittsburgh), PECO (Philadelphia), FirstEnergy Pennsylvania (Reading), PPL Electric (Allentown), AEP Ohio (Columbus), Ohio Edison (Akron), Cleveland Electric Illuminating (Cleveland), Toledo Edison (Toledo), Duke Energy Ohio (Cincinnati), AES Ohio (Dayton), Dominion Energy Virginia (Virginia Beach), Appalachian Power VA (Roanoke), Appalachian Power WV (Charleston), Mon Power (Morgantown), Potomac Edison (Martinsburg), DTE Electric (Detroit), Consumers Energy (Grand Rapids), Entergy Mississippi (Jackson), Mississippi Power (Gulfport).
Limitations, stated plainly
- One city per utility stands in for the whole territory.
- Install cost is a state average, not utility-specific.
- Export credits are typical values. West Virginia's roughly 9¢ new-customer rate is applied to all three West Virginia utilities, and some utilities' export rates vary by hour or season.
- FirstEnergy Pennsylvania (the former Penelec, Met-Ed, West Penn Power and Penn Power) reports to EIA as one company, so it has one row.
- This page uses a newer 12-month rate window than our 50-state map, so state and utility figures won't match exactly.
Free to cite, reproduce or reuse with a link to this page. Download the data (CSV).
Frequently asked questions
Which utility in Pennsylvania has the fastest solar payback in 2026?
Among Pennsylvania's large utilities, Duquesne Light customers (Pittsburgh area) have the fastest simple payback: about 8.7 years for a 12 kW system bought with cash. That is because Duquesne's average residential rate, about 25.1¢/kWh from August 2025 to July 2026, is the highest in the state, and Pennsylvania credits exported solar 1:1 at the retail rate. This estimate includes no federal tax credit and no state incentives.
How long does solar take to pay off in West Virginia?
It depends on your utility. Based on average rates from August 2025 to July 2026, a 12 kW cash-purchased system pays back in about 19.0 years for Appalachian Power customers, 20.9 years for Potomac Edison customers and 21.4 years for Mon Power customers. New West Virginia solar customers are credited only about 9¢/kWh for exported power, well below retail. These estimates include no federal tax credit and no incentives.
Is solar worth it with Dominion Energy in Virginia?
For a typical 12 kW system bought with cash, Dominion Energy Virginia customers see a simple payback of about 10.5 years, based on Dominion's average residential rate of about 17.0¢/kWh (August 2025 to July 2026) and 1:1 retail credit for exported power. Whether that is worth it depends on your roof and your actual quote.
How long does solar take to pay off with DTE or Consumers Energy in Michigan?
About 11.8 years for DTE Electric customers and 12.1 years for Consumers Energy customers, for a 12 kW cash-purchased system. Both utilities averaged about 21.5 to 21.7¢/kWh for residential customers from August 2025 to July 2026, and Michigan's inflow/outflow billing credits exported power at roughly 75–80% of retail. No federal tax credit or incentives are included.
Why does solar pay off faster in Pittsburgh than in sunnier places?
Payback depends mostly on how much each kWh of solar saves you, and that is set by your electricity rate and how your utility credits exports. Pittsburgh gets less sun than any other city in this study, but Duquesne Light's high residential rate (about 25.1¢/kWh) and 1:1 export credit mean each kWh saves more. Across the 19 utilities studied, the value of each solar kWh explained about 82% of the variation in payback and sunshine about 2%.
Is the 30% federal solar tax credit included in these payback numbers?
No. The federal Residential Clean Energy Credit (Section 25D) is not allowed for expenditures made after December 31, 2025, and the IRS treats an expenditure as made when installation is completed, not when you sign or pay. None of the payback figures on this page include it.
Why is my utility's rate different from my bill?
The rates on this page are 12-month averages of what each utility's residential customers on standard service paid, including supply and delivery. Your own rate may differ if you buy electricity from a retail supplier, are on a time-of-use plan, or use much more or less power than average.
Related
Solar Break-Even Map (all 50 states) · Is Solar Worth It in 2026? · What happened to the solar tax credit · Net metering by state · Quote comparison tool